-
3 Reviews
-
-
Writing really needs work
Posted Sep 10, 2008
The Pros
It was an interesting story. Mistaking people is often awkward and embarrassing. You got the feeling that you were hearing this from an adolescent.
The Cons
The writing really needs work, and that's what killed the piece. The same complications in flow kept coming back, so I'll show you some examples.
"her lips looked as though she sucked blood. It was that red."
(first of all, it would be "they", not "it"...)
The second sentence in there was a fragment. Instead of a period, you could use a comma or a semi colon.
" I walked back over to the table (where I left my bag),"
Don't use parenthesis in the story unless you need to. The statement in parenthesis could easily have been incorporated into the sentence, and flowed fine.
Those weren't the only problem parts, just an example of what should be fixed throughout the piece.
I felt the third paragraph really needed work. It was kind of all over the place, and hard to follow.
The piece really just.... didn't come together very well. It felt sloppy.
Final Thoughts
It's an interesting story, but it should be written. Maybe give it a few years, look back at the event, and write it with more reflection and writing flow.
It's good that you're writing, though. Keep working on it.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
-
An Honest Look
Posted Aug 17, 2008
The Pros
It seemed real. I can believe you when you say the stepmother thought you were her child, because you thoroughly described her and took a good long look at her to see what was really inside. If you had not been so thorough, I would have voted negative on this article just because of the terrible tagline. (No offense) But I was pleasantly surprised by this sincere view on a touchy situation, and I thank you for it.
The Cons
There were a few punctuation errors, and I didn't really like the one paragraph form you put the article in. Nothing else to report, though.
Final Thoughts
Good job. Hope she doesn't make the same mistake again. :)
1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
-
I liked it
Posted Aug 17, 2008
The Pros
A very short story with a character without a name was written very well. In such a short piece, I felt there was a decent amount of character development.
The Cons
Cant really think of any...
Final Thoughts
In the end, the story really made you think. In my honest opinion, those are the best kind.
3 out of 4 people found this review helpful.
You must be logged in to review this article.
Click here to register.